Turtle Creek Reservoir Fishing Lake Guide

Turtle Creek Reservoir Fishing Lake Guide

Nestled in the rolling hills of Indiana, Turtle Creek Reservoir is a hidden treasure for fishing enthusiasts. Located in Sullivan County, this reservoir offers a picturesque setting with clear waters and a diverse fish population. Whether you’re a seasoned angler or just starting out, Turtle Creek Reservoir provides an ideal spot for a relaxing and productive fishing trip. This guide will give you all the details you need to make the most of your visit to Turtle Creek Reservoir.

Turtle Creek Reservoir Fishing Details

Before you head out, here are some key details about Turtle Creek Reservoir:

• Water Surface: 1,550 acres
• Shoreline: Approximately 18 miles
• Average Depth: 22 feet
• Max Depth: 50 feet
• Surface Elevation: 493 feet
• Location: Sullivan County, Indiana
• Coordinates: 39.0122° N, 87.4311° W
• Accessibility: Public access available via boat ramps and fishing piers
• Type of Lake: Reservoir
• Lake Amenities:
  • Boat ramps
  • Fishing piers
  • Picnic areas
  • Restrooms
  • Hiking trails
  • Nearby parks

Types of Fish in Turtle Creek Reservoir

Turtle Creek Reservoir is home to a wide variety of fish species, making it a fantastic spot for anglers. Here are some of the most common fish you can find in the lake and where they’re usually located:

• Largemouth Bass: Often found near structures like fallen trees, docks, and weed beds. They are more active during early morning and late afternoon.
• Bluegill: Typically found in shallow waters near the shoreline, especially around submerged vegetation and brush piles.
• Crappie: Look for crappie in deeper waters during the day, often around submerged structures. They tend to move closer to the shore in the early morning and late evening.
• Channel Catfish: These fish are usually found in deeper waters and near the bottom, especially around structures like logs and rocks.
• Hybrid Striped Bass: Commonly found in open waters and near drop-offs.
• Flathead Catfish: Typically found in deeper waters and near the bottom, often around structures.
• Yellow Perch: Found in schools, often in deeper waters near the bottom. They can also be found near weed edges and drop-offs.

Best Fishing Baits, Lures, and Tackle Recommendations

Choosing the right bait and tackle can make a big difference in your fishing success at Turtle Creek Reservoir. Here are some recommendations for each type of fish:

• Largemouth Bass:
  • Baits: Live bait like minnows and nightcrawlers.
  • Lures: Soft plastic worms, crankbaits, and spinnerbaits.
  • Tackle: Medium to heavy spinning or baitcasting rod with a strong line.
• Bluegill:
  • Baits: Worms, crickets, and small insects.
  • Lures: Tiny jigs and spinners.
  • Tackle: Light spinning rod with a light line.
• Crappie:
  • Baits: Minnows and small worms.
  • Lures: Small jigs and tube baits.
  • Tackle: Light to medium spinning rod with a light line.
• Channel Catfish:
  • Baits: Nightcrawlers, chicken liver, and stink baits.
  • Lures: Not commonly used, but large jigs can work.
  • Tackle: Medium to heavy spinning or baitcasting rod with a strong line.
• Hybrid Striped Bass:
  • Baits: Shad and minnows.
  • Lures: Jigs, crankbaits, and spoons.
  • Tackle: Medium to heavy spinning rod with a strong line.
• Flathead Catfish:
  • Baits: Live bait like bluegill and shad.
  • Lures: Not commonly used.
  • Tackle: Heavy spinning or baitcasting rod with a strong line.
• Yellow Perch:
  • Baits: Worms, minnows, and small insects.
  • Lures: Small jigs and spinners.
  • Tackle: Light spinning rod with a light line.

Best Fishing Spot Locations at Turtle Creek Reservoir Fishing

Finding the right spot can significantly enhance your fishing experience. Here are some of the best locations around Turtle Creek Reservoir for a successful catch:

1. North Shore: This area is known for its clear waters and abundant vegetation, making it an ideal spot for bluegill and bass fishing. The shallow waters near the shore are perfect for bluegill, while the weed beds are great for bass.
2. East Bay: This bay offers deeper waters and plenty of submerged structures, making it a hotspot for crappie and perch. Early morning and late evening are particularly productive in this area.
3. South End: Known for its weedy areas and gradual drop-offs, this spot is excellent for channel catfish and flathead catfish fishing. The vegetation provides good cover for these species.
4. Public Fishing Pier: Located near the boat ramp, this pier provides easy access to deeper waters where hybrid striped bass are often found. It’s a great spot for both day and night fishing.
5. Boat Ramps and Docks: These areas are convenient for launching your boat and are also good spots for catching fish that hang around the structures, such as bass and crappie.

Fishing Tips and Recommendations for Turtle Creek Reservoir Fishing

To make the most out of your fishing trip to Turtle Creek Reservoir, keep these tips in mind:

• Time of Day: Early morning and late evening are generally the best times to fish, as the fish are more active during these periods.
• Weather Conditions: Overcast days are often better for fishing than bright, sunny days. Fish are more likely to be closer to the surface when it’s cloudy.
• Seasons: Spring and fall are typically the best seasons for fishing at Turtle Creek Reservoir. The cooler water temperatures make fish more active and easier to catch.
• Fishing License: Make sure you have a valid Indiana fishing license before you head out. You can purchase one online or at local sporting goods stores.
• Safety First: Always wear a life jacket when you’re on a boat, and make sure you have all the necessary safety equipment on board.
• Respect the Environment: Follow all local fishing regulations and practice catch and release whenever possible to help maintain the lake’s fish population.

Turtle Creek Reservoir Fishing Reviews

Here are some positive reviews from anglers who have enjoyed fishing at Turtle Creek Reservoir:

1. John S. from Fort Wayne, IN: “I’ve been fishing at Turtle Creek Reservoir for years, and it’s always a great experience. The bass fishing is fantastic, and the scenery is beautiful. Highly recommend!”
2. Sarah L. from Indianapolis, IN: “Turtle Creek Reservoir is my go-to spot for crappie fishing. The fish are plentiful, and the quiet, peaceful setting makes for a relaxing day out on the water.”
3. Mike R. from South Bend, IN: “I love fishing for hybrid striped bass at Turtle Creek Reservoir. The weedy areas and drop-offs are perfect spots, and I’ve caught some really big ones here.”
4. Emily K. from Muncie, IN: “The public fishing pier is great for families. My kids love catching bluegill, and it’s easy to access. We always have a fun time here.”
5. Tom D. from Warsaw, IN: “Turtle Creek Reservoir never disappoints. The variety of fish and the beautiful surroundings make it one of the best fishing spots in Indiana.”

Top-Rated Closest RV Parks, RV Resorts, and Campgrounds

If you’re planning to stay overnight or for a few days, here are five top-rated RV parks, RV resorts, and campgrounds near Turtle Creek Reservoir:

1. Shakamak State Park
   • Features: Fishing lakes, hiking trails, swimming pool, playgrounds
   • Amenities: Full hookups, restrooms, showers, camp store
   • Hookups: Electric, water, sewer
   • Distance to Lake: 5 miles
2. Minnehaha Fish and Wildlife Area
   • Features: Wildlife viewing, fishing ponds, hunting areas
   • Amenities: Primitive camping, restrooms, picnic areas
   • Hookups: None (primitive camping)
   • Distance to Lake: 8 miles
3. Greene-Sullivan State Forest
   • Features: Fishing lakes, hiking trails, hunting areas, picnic spots
   • Amenities: Primitive camping, restrooms, showers
   • Hookups: None (primitive camping)
   • Distance to Lake: 10 miles
4. Cagles Mill Lake (Lieber State Recreation Area)
   • Features: Boat ramps, hiking trails, picnic areas, swimming beach
   • Amenities: Full hookups, restrooms, showers, camp store
   • Hookups: Electric, water, sewer
   • Distance to Lake: 12 miles
5. Hilltop Campground
   • Features: Scenic views, fishing ponds, nature trails
   • Amenities: Full hookups, restrooms, showers, laundry facilities
   • Hookups: Electric, water, sewer
   • Distance to Lake: 6 miles

Turtle Creek Reservoir Fishing Summary

Turtle Creek Reservoir in Indiana is truly a fishing paradise. With its clear waters, diverse fish population, and beautiful surroundings, it’s no wonder why so many anglers love coming here. Whether you’re targeting largemouth bass, bluegill, crappie, channel catfish, hybrid striped bass, flathead catfish, or yellow perch, there’s something for everyone. Remember to bring the right bait, lures, and tackle, and take advantage of the best fishing spots around the lake. With the helpful tips and recommendations provided, you’re sure to have a successful and enjoyable fishing trip. And if you plan to stay overnight, the nearby RV parks and campgrounds offer great options for a comfortable and convenient stay. Happy fishing!

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) for Turtle Creek Reservoir Fishing

1. Do I need a fishing license to fish at Turtle Creek Reservoir?
   • Yes, you need a valid Indiana fishing license to fish at Turtle Creek Reservoir. Licenses can be purchased online or at local sporting goods stores.
2. What is the best time of day to fish at Turtle Creek Reservoir?
   • Early morning and late evening are generally the best times to fish, as the fish are more active during these periods.
3. What are the most common fish species found in Turtle Creek Reservoir?
   • The most common fish species in Turtle Creek Reservoir are largemouth bass, bluegill, crappie, channel catfish, hybrid striped bass, flathead catfish, and yellow perch.
4. Are there any public fishing piers at Turtle Creek Reservoir?
   • Yes, there is a public fishing pier near the boat ramp, providing easy access to deeper waters.
5. What are some good spots for catching channel catfish at Turtle Creek Reservoir?
   • The south end of the lake, with its weedy areas and gradual drop-offs, is an excellent spot for channel catfish fishing.

And there you have it! Everything you need to know about fishing at Turtle Creek Reservoir. Whether you’re planning a day trip or a longer stay, Turtle Creek Reservoir offers a fantastic fishing experience. Tight lines and happy fishing!