Cagles Mill Lake Fishing Guide

Cagles Mill Lake Fishing Guide

Hey there, fishing fans! Welcome to your ultimate guide to fishing at Cagles Mill Lake in Indiana. If you’re looking for a fantastic fishing spot with plenty of amenities and a great community, then you’re in the right place. Let’s dive into everything you need to know about Cagles Mill Lake!

About Cagles Mill Lake Fishing

Cagles Mill Lake, also known as Cataract Lake, is a stunning reservoir in the heart of Indiana. Created in 1952 by the Army Corps of Engineers for flood control, this lake has become a haven for outdoor enthusiasts and anglers alike. Nestled in the scenic rolling hills of west-central Indiana, the lake offers a serene escape with its beautiful landscapes and diverse wildlife.

The lake is part of the Lieber State Recreation Area and Cataract Falls State Recreation Area, providing visitors with a variety of recreational activities. From fishing and boating to hiking and picnicking, there’s something for everyone at Cagles Mill Lake.

Cagles Mill Lake Fishing Details

Here’s a detailed look at the essential details about Cagles Mill Lake:

• Water Surface: 1,400 acres
• Shoreline: Approximately 20 miles
• Average Depth: 20 feet
• Max Depth: 55 feet
• Surface Elevation: 636 feet
• Location: Putnam and Owen counties, Indiana
• Coordinates: 39.4556° N, 86.8128° W
• Accessibility: Easily accessible via State Road 42. Plenty of parking available for vehicles and boats.
• Type of Lake: Reservoir
• Lake Amenities: Public boat ramps, picnic areas, restrooms, swimming beaches, fishing piers, hiking trails, and nearby bait and tackle shops.

Types of Fish in Cagles Mill Lake

Cagles Mill Lake is home to a diverse range of fish species, making it a hotspot for anglers. Here’s what you can expect to catch:

• Largemouth Bass: Typically found in the shallow, weedy areas of the lake. They are most active in the early morning and late evening.
• Smallmouth Bass: Found near rocky shorelines and underwater structures. Spring and fall are the best times to catch them.
• Bluegill: Often found near the shoreline in shallow waters. Look for them around docks and submerged vegetation.
• Crappie: They love hiding around submerged trees and brush piles. They are more active during the spring and fall.
• Channel Catfish: Prefer deeper waters with a soft, muddy bottom. Night fishing can be particularly rewarding for catfish.
• Walleye: Usually found in deeper waters near the bottom. They are most active during dawn and dusk.
• Flathead Catfish: Found near underwater structures and deeper areas of the lake. They are active mostly at night.
• White Bass: Found in schools in open water, especially during their spawning run in the spring.

Best Fishing Baits, Lures, and Tackle for Cagles Mill Lake Fishing

Choosing the right bait and tackle is crucial for a successful fishing trip. Here are some recommendations for Cagles Mill Lake:

• Largemouth Bass:
  • Baits: Live minnows, plastic worms, and crayfish.
  • Lures: Spinnerbaits, crankbaits, and topwater lures.
  • Tackle: Medium to heavy action rods with 10-20 lb test line.
• Smallmouth Bass:
  • Baits: Crayfish, live minnows, and nightcrawlers.
  • Lures: Jigs, tube baits, and crankbaits.
  • Tackle: Medium action rods with 6-12 lb test line.
• Bluegill:
  • Baits: Live worms, crickets, and small insects.
  • Lures: Tiny jigs, spinners, and small spoons.
  • Tackle: Light action rods with 4-6 lb test line.
• Crappie:
  • Baits: Minnows and small shad.
  • Lures: Jigs with soft plastic bodies, small crankbaits.
  • Tackle: Light to medium action rods with 4-8 lb test line.
• Channel Catfish:
  • Baits: Chicken liver, stink baits, and nightcrawlers.
  • Lures: Rarely used; stick to bait.
  • Tackle: Medium to heavy action rods with 12-30 lb test line.
• Walleye:
  • Baits: Nightcrawlers, leeches, and minnows.
  • Lures: Jigs, crankbaits, and spinner rigs.
  • Tackle: Medium to heavy action rods with 10-20 lb test line.
• Flathead Catfish:
  • Baits: Live baitfish like bluegill or shad.
  • Lures: Not commonly used; prefer live bait.
  • Tackle: Heavy action rods with 20-50 lb test line.
• White Bass:
  • Baits: Live shad, minnows, and worms.
  • Lures: Small spinners, spoons, and crankbaits.
  • Tackle: Medium action rods with 6-12 lb test line.

Best Fishing Spot Locations at Cagles Mill Lake Fishing

Finding the right spot can make all the difference. Here are some top locations at Cagles Mill Lake:

• Cataract Falls: The area near Cataract Falls is excellent for bass and crappie. The moving water and rocky areas provide great habitat.
• Lieber SRA: This area is known for bluegill and crappie. Fish around the docks and submerged brush piles.
• Dam Area: The deeper waters near the dam are ideal for walleye and channel catfish.
• North Shore: This area is great for largemouth bass, especially near the weed beds.
• South Inlets: These inlets are perfect for smallmouth bass and white bass, with plenty of rocky structures and submerged vegetation.

Fishing Tips and Recommendations for Cagles Mill Lake Fishing

Here are some handy tips to improve your fishing experience at Cagles Mill Lake:

• Early Morning and Late Evening: Fish are more active during these times, so plan your trip accordingly.
• Weather Matters: Overcast days can be great for fishing as fish are more likely to be near the surface.
• Proper Gear: Make sure to use the right gear for the type of fish you’re targeting.
• Stay Quiet: Fish can be spooked by noise, so try to keep quiet and avoid making too much commotion.
• Use Local Bait: Local bait shops often have the best bait for the area, so check with them for recommendations.
• Fishing License: Don’t forget to get your Indiana fishing license before you start.

Cagles Mill Lake Fishing Reviews

Here are some positive reviews from anglers who’ve fished at Cagles Mill Lake:

1. John D.: “Cagles Mill Lake is my favorite fishing spot. The bass fishing is fantastic, and the scenery is just beautiful.”
2. Lisa M.: “I caught my biggest walleye here! The lake is well-maintained, and there are plenty of spots to fish from.”
3. Tom S.: “Great place for a family fishing trip. My kids love catching bluegill near the shore.”
4. Sarah W.: “I’ve been fishing here for years, and it never disappoints. The variety of fish is amazing.”
5. Mike H.: “The facilities are top-notch, and the local community is very friendly. Highly recommend this lake for any angler.”

Top-Rated Closest RV Parks, RV Resorts, and Campgrounds

If you’re planning an extended stay, here are some top-rated RV parks and campgrounds near Cagles Mill Lake:

1. Lieber State Recreation Area:
   • Features: Full hookups, Wi-Fi, swimming pool, playground, and laundry facilities.
   • Distance: 1 mile from Cagles Mill Lake.
2. Cataract Falls State Recreation Area:
   • Features: Electric and water hookups, picnic areas, fishing pond, and boat rentals.
   • Distance: 3 miles from Cagles Mill Lake.
3. Raccoon State Recreation Area:
   • Features: Electric hookups, restrooms, picnic areas, and boat ramps.
   • Distance: 15 miles from Cagles Mill Lake.
4. McCormick’s Creek State Park:
   • Features: Water and electric hookups, swimming beach, playground, and general store.
   • Distance: 12 miles from Cagles Mill Lake.
5. Cagles Mill Lake Campground:
   • Features: Full hookups, swimming pool, nature trails, and clubhouse.
   • Distance: 2 miles from Cagles Mill Lake.

Cagles Mill Lake Fishing Summary

Cagles Mill Lake is a top-tier fishing destination that offers something for everyone. Whether you’re a seasoned angler or just starting out, you’ll find the perfect spot and plenty of fish to catch. The beautiful surroundings and excellent amenities make it a great place for a fishing trip, family outing, or a weekend getaway. So, pack your gear, grab your fishing license, and head over to Cagles Mill Lake for an unforgettable fishing experience.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) for Cagles Mill Lake Fishing

1. Do I need a fishing license to fish at Cagles Mill Lake?
   • Yes, an Indiana fishing license is required for anyone 18 years or older.
2. What are the best times of year to fish at Cagles Mill Lake?
   • Spring and fall are generally the best times, but summer can also be good, especially early in the morning or late in the evening.
3. Can I rent a boat at Cagles Mill Lake?
   • Yes, there are local businesses that offer boat rentals near the lake.
4. Are there any restrictions on the type of bait I can use?
   • It’s always best to check local regulations, but most standard baits like live minnows and worms are allowed.
5. Is Cagles Mill Lake family-friendly?
   • Absolutely! The lake has plenty of amenities and activities that make it a great spot for families.

There you have it, folks! Everything you need to know about fishing at Cagles Mill Lake. Whether you’re planning a day trip or a longer stay, this guide will help you make the most of your fishing adventure. Happy fishing!